How to Get Useful Feedback From People Who Aren't Professional Editors

You're going to show this essay to a parent, a friend, a teacher — people who care about you but aren't trained editors. Here's how to get something actually useful out of that, instead of a well-meaning "it's great!"

Worth saying first: these readers can do something no trained editor can. They know you. They're the only people who can tell you whether the person on the page is recognizably you, which is the single hardest thing to check on your own. The trick is asking them in a way that lets them use what they know.

"Is this good?" is the wrong question.

It invites exactly one honest answer from someone who loves you — yes. It's not a useless question because people are dishonest; it's useless because it doesn't give them anything specific to evaluate. Replace it with questions that produce real, actionable answers.

Adding "be honest" doesn't fix it either. The problem isn't that your reader is holding back a harsh verdict they'd deliver if pressed. It's that "good" isn't a thing a reader can observe. Ask what they noticed, and they can answer accurately. Ask for a judgment, and they'll give you encouragement, which is the correct thing for someone who loves you to give.

Better questions to actually ask

• "What's the one thing you remember most after reading this?" — reveals what actually lands, rather than what they think they should praise.
• "Where did you get a little bored or start skimming?" — reveals pacing problems people rarely volunteer unprompted.
• "Does this sound like me, or does it sound like I was trying to sound like something else?" — reveals voice drift better than almost any other question.
• "What questions do you still have after reading this?" — reveals gaps and unclear moments.

Two small things that make these work better. Ask them after your reader has finished, not while they're reading — a person being watched reads differently and will start narrating reassurance. And write down what they say rather than arguing with it in the moment. The urge to explain what you meant is strong, and explaining is exactly what the essay has to do without you in the room.

Give your reader the actual prompt.

Someone reading your essay without knowing the actual prompt can't tell you whether it answers the question. They can only tell you whether it's well-written in general. Always give the prompt alongside the essay, along with the word limit, and ask directly whether the essay answers what's being asked.

Give them the prompt and nothing else. It's tempting to explain what you were going for first — the story behind the story, the part that didn't fit — but a reader who's been briefed can no longer tell you whether the essay works, because they're now reading with information the admissions reader won't have. Save the explanation for after their answer.

Ask one specific reader for one specific thing.

Instead of sending your essay to five people and asking "thoughts?", it's often more useful to ask one trusted reader a narrower question — just the opening, just whether the ending feels earned, just whether the voice sounds like you. A focused answer from one person usually beats five vague reactions from five people.

Five readers also create a specific problem. Each one will suggest changes in their own register, and an essay that absorbs all of them ends up written in a committee's voice rather than yours. It's the most common way a fifth draft comes out flatter than the third.

Notice the difference between "I'd change this" and "this doesn't work."

Any reader will have personal preferences about wording or structure that aren't necessarily problems, just their taste. Try to distinguish between "I personally would have written it differently," which is interesting but optional, and "I couldn't tell what you meant here," which is a real problem worth fixing. Not all feedback carries equal weight.

A rule that holds up well: trust your readers on where the experience broke down, and be skeptical of their fixes. People are reliable reporters of their own confusion, boredom, and surprise — if someone says they got lost in the third paragraph, they got lost, and no amount of your explaining will unlose them. But the change they propose is a guess, often aimed at the symptom. The confusion is data. The suggested rewrite is an opinion.

When someone rewrites your sentences

Sometimes a reader hands the essay back with their own wording in it. This is almost always well-intentioned, and it's usually a sign they hit a real problem — nobody rewrites a sentence that read easily.

You can take the diagnosis without taking the words. Look at what they changed and ask what was wrong with the original: was it unclear, too long, too flat, saying two things at once? Then fix that in your own voice. An essay that quietly accumulates a parent's sentences reads, to an admissions officer, exactly like an essay with a parent's sentences in it.

Want to check the prompt question without asking anyone? Does This Answer the Prompt is a free tool that reads your draft against the question you were asked.

Keep reading

Want help applying this to your own essay?

See how Margin works on a real draft, then decide whether you want to bring it yours.

Explore more Resources →